people were watching us. We all began acting as casual as possible. Only our words were full of panic. We just had to hope that no one was listening.
âNothing specific. She was smooth about it. Thatâs what worries me. She kept asking me about how much time I spent in New York and then she just slipped in how much she loved Brooklyn and asked me if Iâd ever been there.â
âWell, that doesnât tell us much,â Michael replied. âSounds like normal conversation to me.â
âYeah, it sounded that way to me too. But it didnât feel normal.â I looked at Michael again. âWhatâs she doing now?â Michael was the only one who could watch her without it being obvious that weâd spotted her.
âSheâs sitting at the bar. She ordered a drink.â
âWhatâs she drinking?â It was an important question. If she was drinking alcohol, then we would know that I was overreacting. If she were on the job, sheâd stay sober.
âClear drink. Regular glass. Lime,â Michael replied. âCould be gin or vodka. Could be club soda.â Michael knew the score too.
âWhy didnât you say something last night?â Jared asked.
âBecause last night, it didnât feel right. Tonight, two nights in a rowâtonight it feels dangerous. Whatâs she doing, Michael?â
âNot much, just sitting there, nursing her drink. A couple times, though, sheâs made eye contact with the big black dude in the corner.â
âYou ever see him before?â I asked Michael.
âNope. First time. Can you make him out?â
I picked up my beer, pretended to take a sip, and leaned back in my chair to see if I could get a good look at the man standing in the corner. Then I saw him. I recognized him immediately. âWeâre made,â I said.
âWhat do you mean?â Michael asked. âYou know that guy?â
âYeah, thatâs my cabbie. He drove me here from Atlantic City. Weâre made. No doubt about it.â I nearly took a real swig of beer. It was a reflex. Instead, I just pressed the bottle to my lips, not letting a drop slip through. Then I placed the beer back on the table. I didnât know what would be in store that night, but I knew that I needed to keep all my faculties. âSo, whatâs our plan?â I asked. Michael and I both looked to Jared. Thatâs how it was. Michael was the party. Jared had the plans. I still havenât figured out what my part was.
âDoes she know about us?â Jared asked, motioning to him and Michael.
âWell, if she didnât before, she probably would have guessed by now since weâre sitting at the same fucking table.â I said. âBut, yeah, I told her last night that you guys were my friends.â
âWeâre going to have to split up,â Jared said without any hesitation.
âThereâs another guy at the other end of the bar,â Michael interrupted. âHeâs definitely with her too. Late thirties, white, gray before his time but in pretty good shape, small scar under his left eye.â I again took a fake sip from my drink but I couldnât get a good look at the new guy. From what I could see, I didnât recognize him. âSplitting up sounds like a bat-shit stupid idea to me,â Michael said. His face betrayed his emotions for the first time since weâd started playing our little game of pretend.
âEasy, Michael,â I said. âLetâs not give anything away just yet. Why do you think we should split up, Jared?â
âItâs the only chance we have here. We canât fight them. We have to run. If we run together we all get caught.â
âI donât see why we canât fight them,â Michael replied. âWe split up and the odds of all three of us making it out are pretty slim.â Michael looked at me when he said this. We all figured the same