know anything.â
The two men met for breakfast at Du-parâs restaurant in the San Fernando Valley. Thirty years later, the chronology of this conversation differs a bit, depending on which of them you talk to (âMagnoli completely makes up shit,â says Cavallo. âSometimes heâs very flattering to himself, and sometimes heâs just wrongâ). According to Cavallo, they sat down and he offered Magnoli the chance to direct the movie for $75,000. âNow, he doesnât have a glass to piss in,â says Cavallo. âHe says, âI pass.â I fucking went crazy. I lost my cool. I say, âHow the fuck do you pass? Why?â He said, âOh, itâs so square.â I said, âI know itâs squareâcan you do something about it? Do you have any ideas?â He says, âGive me a week.â
âWe meet again a week later, and basically, he does the movie standing up, jumping up and downâheâs a very athletic kid. [And] we make a deal.â
Magnoliâs account of his own performance is quite similar,but he claims there was just one meeting, and that his conjuring of the movieâs narrative was much more spontaneous. When he asserted that what the movie needed was a writer/director who would spend time with the musicians and write something more authentic, Cavallo asked him what the story would be.
âIt was one of those moments when all the bells go off,â Magnoli says. âI looked at him and I just started talking, and in five to seven minutes, I pitched him Purple Rain . In elementary and high school, I was a drummer, so that was enough to give me some insight into the troubles and tribulations of a performer. The Blinn script gave me the characters. I had enough information that I could just pitch. And Iâm an excitable guy; I was jumping up in the air, getting down on the ground.
â[Cavallo] looked at me and said, âThatâs a hell of a story. So now what are you going to do?â I said that the next day I would go to Minneapolis. It was a Friday. I would go and meet Prince and pitch that story. Then Sunday I would come home, and Iâll come back with a motion picture or I wonât.â
They both agree that it was Magnoliâs vision of the movieâs first scene that helped close the deal. âHe got me excited by describing the opening,â says Cavallo. âHe said, âTake the ending of The Godfather and make it the opening of our picture.â Prince is doing a song, the elevator comes up, the girl is coming from the airport, hustling her way inâall the characters are introduced, and you keep cutting back to the stage. Prince is putting makeup on, getting on his bike, he rides up to the place, the bar scene with the Time, Apollonia pulls a scam andgets in, you see everybody. So he described that scene, and I went nuts.â
âI instinctively conceived an opening musical number in which we could introduce other characters and minimize the need for dialogue,â says Magnoli. âI mentioned the ending of The Godfather , all those cuts to the other charactersâmoving from Michael Corleone at the church, with those words going all over the other scenes and characters, and that gave him a visual.â
(It isnât actually the final scene in The Godfather that Magnoli was referencingâthatâs the famous moment when Michael Corleone denies his involvement in the mob to his wifeâbut the penultimate scene, often called the âbaptism sequence.â For five minutes, Francis Ford Coppola cuts back and forth between Michaelâs godsonâs baptism and a series of murders of the Corleone familyâs enemies. Itâs interesting to note that the director was unhappy with the montage, which used sixty-seven shots, until one of the filmâs editors suggested he lay an organ track over the entire sequence: in an inversion of the Purple Rain concept, in