necessary?â
âItâs this or shave her head,â I rumble, tightening my grip on Helen.
âBut Miss Annieââ
âYou do it, then,â I cry, thrusting the brush at her. I turn Helen loose, and as she blunders toward the feel of her motherâs footsteps, I see a shiver of terror pass over Mrs. Kellerâs face. She takes a step back and Helen crashes into her.
âI canât control her, Miss Annie,â she cries. âYou know that.â
The look on her face siphons away all my fury. Fine lines lie etched all along the edges of her delicate mouth, and her eyes swim with hurt. I slink from the bed, pulling the Perkins doll with me, and put it into Helenâs thrashing arms. The tide of her anger turns, and Helen retreats to the corner with her plaything. âOh, Mrs. Keller,â I sigh. âDonât you see? The problem isnât Helen, itâs you.â
âMe?â She looks stung.
âAll of you. You and the captain and Miss Eveline. Youâve given Helen nothing but pity, and itâs turned her into a tyrant.â
âWeâve been through this more than once,â she says, shaking her head. âHow can I expect her to behave any other way?â
âYou expect better behavior from the captainâshounds than from your own daughter. She needs discipline, not coddling.â
âHow can I discipline her? She doesnât understand.â
âShe understands plentyâeven a dog understands when his master scolds him, and Helenâs smarter than any dog I know. She knows all she has to do is throw a fit or dampen her cheeks, and the world is hers. She understands what you donâtâthat when you or the captain are here, I have no power over her.â
âWhat would you have us do? Weâre her parents.â
At last I can speak the words that have been brewing in my head: âLet me take her away somewhere.â
Her head jerks up. âAway? Why?â
I understand her fear. The idea frightens me a little.
âIâve tried everything I know. I canât win her loveâshe wonât have any caressing from me. I canât win her confidence because she accepts everything I do for her as a matter of course. Thereâs no coaxing or compromising with her. She will or she wonât, and thatâs the end of it. Sympathy, affection, and fairness mean nothing to her. Iâve studied, planned, and prepared, but nothing Iâve learned fits. All I know is that I canât accomplish anything in this house. As long as Helen can run to you for protection, she wonât learn a thing.â
âDoes she need protection, Miss Annie?â
The word strikes me like a barb. âWhat do
you
think, Mrs. Keller?â I blurt, displaying all my wounds at once: a broken tooth, bruised and battered shins, arms decorated with scratches and bite marks. âAnd if you ever scrub those filthy hands of hers, youâll find most of my skin under her nails!â Mrs. Kellerâs eyes flutter across my injuries. She reaches for me, then draws back to rub at a sore spot above her own elbow.
âI wonât say Iâm not harsh with Helen,â I tell her, my tone softer, âbut youâve never found a mark on her, have you, now?â
She shakes her head, then asks, after a moment, âHow long would you keep her?â
âUntil she learns to obey and depend on me. A few weeks at least.â
For a long time she says nothing. I feel my hand moving in and out of the silence like a needle through cloth. I look down.
P-l-e-a-s-e,
Iâm spelling to myself.
Please, Mrs. Keller, please.
She doesnât speak for so long my knees begin to ache, but the quiet hangs too heavy to disturb.
Finally she looks up and says, âIâll talk it over with the captain.â
The captain. Oh, all is lost now.
I nod at Mrs. Keller, my head reeling. She goes out of the room. My feet carry me