couldnât. There were reasons.â Already she had grasped that it was useless talking to Crisp like that. âThe fact is, I had some diamonds which my mother left me. And I asked Lord Watlington, and he said heâd very kindly sell them for me. And so he couldnât give me the money at our last meeting because he didnât know how much theyâd fetch. And I didnât want it sent by post, because Arthur opens everything, and heâs awful with money. Thatâs reasonable enough, isnât it?â
It might be reasonable, thought Crisp, but it wasnât true.
âI wish youâd let me have it, now you know itâs nothing to do with the murder.â
âTake it, if you wish,â said Crisp indifferently, handing it to her. âBut you canât cash it, you know. The banks stop payment at death.â
âThen I shanât get a penny?â It was a horrified whisper.
âOh yes, in time! Provided you can satisfy the executors. Of course, theyâll probably want you to prove the bit about the diamonds before they pay.â
Benscombe suspected her of intending to throw a faint. With a deft compromise of police officer and dancing partner, he removed her.
âThatâs a side-line, isnât it, sir?â he asked.
âI donât see where she fits in,â answered Crisp absently. âMotherâs diamonds, eh! It might be worth while finding out whether Fenchurch knows anything about that five hundred. You can look after that yourself as soon as you get the chance.â
He glanced at the copy of Ralphâs confession.
âThis confounded fellow has made a mess of the Regulations. We canât ignore the confession unless weâre satisfied itâs a hoax. It may or may not be a hoax, but your hunch that itâs genuine has been scuppered by Querk.â
Benscombe looked sheepish.
âThereâs still a chance, sir. Assume that the confession is substantially trueââ
âBut it isnât. He says he struck through the wig, and he didnât.â
â Substantially true, sir, though inaccurate in detail. Iâm thinking of the Sefton-Lyle case. Sefton confessed that he had shot Ashwin. But the bullet was found in the garden, Ashwin having pretended to be hit. And it was Lyle who shot Ashwin nearly an hour later.â
âTwo bangs and two bullets!â grunted Crisp. âHere we have one blow only. And that blow killed Watlington. Also, what about the time?â
âIâm assuming a deliberate lie in the matter of time. That would rope in your theory, sir, that he is trying to protect Miss Lofting.â
âNo luck, boy! Watlingtonâs wife has corroborated the time from that bench in the garden. Cornboise left the study at five fifteenâwas out of the place in his car a few minutes later, and did not return until after six thirty.â
âBut look here, sir! Given that Cornboise is lying and Querk telling the truth, the murderer must have entered the library almost as soon as Querk left it. That points to Miss Lofting, which is absurd.â
Crisp chuckled.
âAttractive girls donât commit murder, do they, laddie!â
âIf theyâre really attractive, they donât have to,â grinned Benscombe. âI was going to say that, if you have Cornboise in again and let him see you know heâs lyingâthen with Querkâs evidence up your sleeveââ
âA rotten place to keep your evidence. We donât need all that diplomacy. Weâll put Cornboise in a bag with Querk and shake âem up together until something drops out. Trot â em in.â
Querk did not trot. He had by now imposed upon himself the stance of a man who is attending a funeral.
âI am glad, Chief Constable,â he said with a hush in his voice, âthat you have taken me at my word. I always feelâbless my soul!â He broke off as Benscombe appeared
Benjamin Baumer, Andrew Zimbalist