down,â she said.
I opened the drawer and saw papers and pens, a pack of playing cards, and a small plastic pill pot, all neatly arranged in front of me. And there, to the right, was a stack of birthday cards. You Are One and Two Today! I flipped them between my hands inside the drawer. They were old, worn. My heart sped up. There were more underneath. Congratulations! You are 3! 4! 5! I turned around to see if Frances was looking over at me. She wasnât. She was filling a glass with water for her pills from a carafe on the table next to the tea. These were Catherineâs cards. They had to be. I felt as if somebody had their hands around my neck. My throat was tight. There was no air. I glanced back at Frances again and then pulled in a deep and painful breath before opening one of the cards to read.
Dear Catherine,
Happy Birthday!
With love,
Amanda, Richard, and Emma
This was Mumâs writing. It was hers. I let my fingers stroke the card where her pen had been. I was close to her, in that moment, closer than Iâd ever been before. I quickly opened another card, my hands still in the drawer.
Dear Catherine
Have a day filled with fun!
Lots of love,
Amanda, Richard, and Emma
And still, another, the same.
From Amanda, Richard, and Emma
And on one, Iâd signed my own name.
Emma
And in another Iâd drawn a smiley face â
For my friend Catherine
My writing was big, scrawled.
âCanât you find them?â Frances asked. I jumped at her voice, and then I took one of the cards and put it in my skirt pocket. It was instinctive. I just knew I had to have the card. To have something that had been touched and held by Mum.
âGot them,â I said, holding the pill pot up to show Frances, and I closed the sideboard drawer.
I went and sat back down and passed over the pills. I watched while Frances opened the pot up and tipped the contents out into the palm of her hand. She was slow. So slow. Arranging and rearranging the pills on the table and then again in her hand. And as I waited I felt anxious, restless.
I looked out the window at the Green.
And suddenly it was there. An almost-immediate pain â and with it that feeling again. My dad. Iâd been waiting for him to come and play. Where had he been?
I turned back to Frances.
âHe didnât come out and play,â I said, and as I said it I felt as if I was still waiting for him now, willing him to come.
âWhat are you talking about?â Frances said, setting down her glass of water on the table in front of her.
âDad. He never came out and played like he said he would. He never came.â
âHe was talking to me,â said Frances.
âTo you? But he was meant to come out and play with me â â I said, and I recognized the child in my voice as I did.
âIâm sure he would have come, but we had things we needed to talk about. What does it matter, Ana?â Frances said.
âIt matters,â I said. âTo me!â
âWhy?â Frances said.
âWhere was Mum?â
âShe was already at the party. Youâd all gone to the party early â around half past five. Amanda was helping with the food. Sheâd baked. She was always baking something. So you and Richard helped Amanda carry the food over to the party and then he brought you over here to see Catherine. The plan was that the four of us would go to the party when it started at half past six. But none of this matters, Ana. None of it. Because it isnât what happened.â
âWeâre going to the river, Catherine. Weâll play hide-and-seek by the river.â
âIf you donât play Iâll tell on you. You have to come or thatâs what Iâll do.â
âWhat were you and Dad talking about?â I asked.
âI donât remember,â Frances said.
âBut he never came,â I said, again. âHeâd promised!â
âYou never could accept