right page?â
I snatched the diary back and flicked through. âItâs gone,â I said. âVanished.â
âAway with the fairies, you mean.â She clicked her tongue. âOr are you going to tell me itâs lemon juice or special elven invisible ink?â
âI thought you said you believed me.â
âI did. That was before you showed me a page with no writing on it.â Her eyebrows started to close in, like hungry wolves round a wounded deer. âWhen I said I wanted an imaginative excuse, I didnât mean something so wildly bizarre that it insults my intelligence.â
âBut it was there,â I protested. âRight there where I was pointing. I saw it.â
She looked at me sideways. âThis seeing-things-thatarenât-there aspect of your characterâs a new one on me,â she said slowly. âIâm not sure Iâm all that happy about it.â
âButââ I stopped dead. Have you ever put your foot in some really deep mud, so that it keeps going on down and down without meeting anything solid? The trick is, under such circumstances, not to thrash about and make sudden violent movements, or you really will get stuck. Same goes, in my limited experience, for protesting your innocence to a sceptical female. Keep still, say nothing, wait for someone to pull you out. Which, to her credit, she immediately proceeded to do.
âMaybe,â she said, in a vaguely conciliatory tone of voice, âyou thought youâd seen it because youâve been so preoccupied lately. And,â she went on, âjust because you imagined some elf stuff once, it doesnât necessarily follow that all the elf stuffâs imaginary.â
âTrue,â I mumbled.
âBesides,â she went on, falling in beside me and starting to walk back towards the main building, âit doesnât actually fit in with the rest of what youâve been telling me about these elves of yours. Like, what you were saying seemed to suggest that theyâre somehow being â well, held against their will. Forced to work as gardeners, or whatever. Anyway, theyâre localised to your dadâs house, and maybe the immediate vicinity. Thatâs a hundred miles away.â
I frowned. âHowâd you make all that out?â I asked.
âIsnât that what you told me? About the elf that died saying death is a sort of freedom, and it was finally outside the limits? Sounds to me like itâd escaped from â well, from somewhere. And then you said about your stepfatherâs garden being so perfect but nobody ever did any work there that you could see. And then you find thereâre elves there, with little spades and things; and your stepfather gets so incredibly hostile when he catches you hanging around the garden. Doesnât it stand to reason that . . .â
âJesus.â
Well, maybe I had thought of it, at least on a subconscious level; but I certainly hadnât consciously fitted together those particulars pieces. Or hadnât allowed myself to, more like. Cru, on the other hand, was under no such disability and now sheâd actually said it out loud, it wasnât ever going to go away.
Pity, that. Iâd wanted understanding and moral support, not to have my nose rubbed in an uncomfortable, possibly life-altering hypothesis. A bit like running to Mummy to have a bumped knee kissed better, to find Mummy waiting for you with a chainsaw and saying sheâs going to have to amputate.
Cru just seemed annoyed that Iâd interrupted her. âWell, doesnât it?â she demanded. âAs far as Iâm concerned, itâs as obvious as an elephant sandwich. To be honest with you, I canât really see how you couldâve failed toââ
Gee , I thought; if sheâs the sensitive, tactful one, I must be really crass. âRight,â I said. âWell, youâve given me