answered him, his voice was so soft that I had to strain to hear.
âI had two brothers, sir.â
âOh? I didnât know that, Ben.â
âDaniel, fourteen years older than I. Franklin, fifteen years older.â
âWhat happened to them, Ben?â
âThe Harkness cave-in. Eighteen ninety-nine. Itâs forgotten by now. They worked together, as a team.â
âI see.â
âWell, that was a good offer from Pittsburgh. Iâm very grateful to you for thinking of me, Mr. Aimesley.â
âI wish it wouldnât end there, Ben. A lawyer is well armed. You can do a lot as a lawyer, Ben.â
âYes, sir. I know that. But first I have to figure out what I want to do.â
Â
3
So my letter to you, dear Alvin, goes on and on. I put it aside yesterday, and later that evening I rummaged through the drawers of my old bedroom chest. Father never changed my room, never got rid of anything, and there in a drawer I found the diary I had kept for three years, from the age of fourteen to the age of seventeen. So you see that I was a very usual young lady who kept a diary during just those years when a girl is expected to. It continues up to a point, and my point was the day I met Ben Holt. Late at night on that day, I made the following entry:
Today I met a divine, awful young man. His name is much more exalted than he is, since he is only a coal miner. His name is Benjamin Renwell Holt, and he has caused me nothing but trouble, so I hope I will never see him again and that Father forgets the whole thing. Cousin Jimmy also arrived.
That was the last entry I ever made in the diary. Can it be that when you first touch the manner and meaning of your existence, a teen-age diary is put aside? Anyway, during dinner, my Cousin Jimmy Aimesley said something about Ben Holt. He had arrived as Ben was leaving, and Father introduced them. I remember that Jimmy was terribly impressed with Benâs size, bearing, and a certain quality of magnetism so striking in Ben, and he mentioned this. Jimmy was small and underweight, and had always admired and envied big men.
âI donât think heâs anything to admire,â I said.
My father raised his brows. âThen you know him, Dorothy?â
âNo, I only opened the door for him.â
âBut you know heâs no one to admire,â my father went on. I think I was forewarned; I knew that tone of my fatherâs; but I had to go on and hit out somehow against Ben, I couldnât stop, and I said,
âHeâs just a miner, but even a minerâs hands and neck could be clean when he comes calling on Sunday.â
Fatherâs face clouded, but he would never allow an argument during dinner. âThatâs enough, Dorothy,â he said quietly. âWeâll discuss this later.â
After dinner, Father gave Jimmy a copy of Mr. Jeromeâs Three Men in a Boat , an old favorite of his which, he felt, would amuse Jimmy and improve his outlook on the world, and motioned me to follow him into his study. Poor Jimmy was no great prize, but to be marched off like this on his first night with us was almost more than I could bear, and in the study, I stared at Father morosely.
Bluntly, with no moral precepts to introduce the matter, Father said, âWeâll stick to the facts, Dorothy. They are more enlightening than speculations on egalitarianism. You feel a personal affront in the fact that Mr. Holt did not remove the signs of his trade before he came calling here.â
âIt is Sunday. He could have washed.â
âIâve raised you poorly,â Father sighed, âbut weâll let that go by the board for the moment. How the hell do you know that he didnât wash?â
I was taken utterly aback, and I simply stared at him. He had never used that word to me before, or the toneâor looked at me in such a cold and melancholy manner. I was speechless, but he went on