to react the way I wanted toâwhich was to shout at him to use another word other than no .
âYou donât get to veto just like that, you know.â
He bit his bottom lip, rolling it under his teeth and taking a deep breath as he stared at me, staring at him. âAnd you donât get to toss out an idea like that without talking to me about it first.â
âIsnât that what weâre doing here?â I asked, sighing with frustration.
âLook, this is not the time or place, Kate. Weâre going to go over there, order some ice cream and hang out with our kids, and weâll talk about this later.â
âFine,â I said, turning and walking toward the ice-cream shop.
Iâm not sure how Iâd expected him to react, and I knew how unfair it was to bring it up like thatâat a time when we really couldnât discuss itâbut it still pissed me off. As retorts of âmy body, my decisionâ tickled my lips, I forced them back knowing what a bullshit response that would be. Of course it wasnât my decision aloneâDavid had to be on board if this was going to happen.
So I needed to figure out how to get David on board.
* * *
Much later, after ice cream, showers for the girls, and barely two words exchanged between David and me, we sat in bleached wooden chairsâfrom my momâs garden patio setâon the rooftop balcony off our bedroom, tumblers of red wine sitting on the table between us untouched.
Sounds of car horns and passersby and a baby crying out an open window a few houses down surrounded us, offering a reprieve from the uncomfortable silence that comes when the angry things you want to say are still mercifully insideâwhere they canât do damage to anyone but you.
âIâm sorry I didnât bring it up before I went to see Dr. Kadari.â In retrospect, sharing this giant decision with my gynecologistâwho I saw once a yearâbefore my husband was probably not the best idea.
âItâs not about that,â he said, swirling the wine in his glass but still not taking a sip. He put the glass back on the table and stretched out his legs, crossing them at his ankles. One flip-flop was slightly askew, but he didnât seem to care. âItâs that you even thought it was a real option.â
I swallowed hard, willing myself to discuss this calmly. âOkay, so why couldnât it be a real option?â
âOh, I donât know. Maybe because we have our own daughters to think about. Or the fact that we have busy lives, and you have said more than once you donât want to have more kids?â
âBut this baby wouldnât be my baby, our baby.â
âYouâre delusional if you think thatâs true,â David said, his words clipped with frustration.
I tried not to cry, in part at the nastiness of his tone, in part because I wanted him so desperately to see it from my perspectiveâsomething that was looking less and less likely with every passing minute. I drained my glass and then took Davidâs.
âWell, cheers to you at least being willing to listen to my side of things,â I said, lifting his tumbler up and taking a huge gulp of wine.
âKate, I donât want to fight with youââ
âThen donât!â The last sip of wineâits tannins bitter in the back of my throatâchoked me, and I coughed violently. David turned sharply to look at me but didnât say anything or ask if I was okay.
Once Iâd stopped coughing, with another sip of wineâmy buzz growing but not dulling the flurry of emotions I was experiencingâI said, âI donât want to fight, either.â
David nodded and took his tumbler from my hands, having a sip of the nearly empty glass. âAre you even sure this is something Hannah and Ben would want?â
âYes.â
âHow? Have you talked with her about it?â His voice was
Cheese Board Collective Staff