a sign of progress. âThey were kidding around. It was a joke. I can take a joke.â
âYou're not getting it,â said Vecque. âIt wasn't a joke. They were teaching you a lesson.â
âWhat do you mean? What lesson?â
âFor what you did to that miner. The one with the failing kidneys.â
âCovert?â
âThat sounds right.â
âHe was sick. I healed him.â
âYou took away his livelihood.â
âNo. I did the opposite. He could barely walk and hardly work. Now he can do what he wants. He even runs around with that crazy group of hisâ¦â He stopped, remembering their confrontation in the snow. âWhat livelihood?â
âMusk,â she said.
âWhat's musk?â
She shook her head. At what point, she wondered, did innocence become ignorance and something to be disdained? âMusk is what they make when they get sick. They collect it and then they sell it. An ounce is worth a week of wages. More than a week. It's precious stuff.â
âSo that's what they were doing in the field? Musk is frozen sweat?â
âSweat plus what their kidneys make. Frozen just because it's easier to collect.â
âSo all those guys were sick?â
Vecque hadn't seen them but imagined so. âNot everybody gets that far. You have to inhale a lot of dust. And it has to be a certain kind of dust. Not copper, but one of the rarer ores. Rokonite, I think. Or gravellium. And even then, most of them just get the breathing problems. Only a handful get the kidney changes, too. For most of the guys it isn't worth the trouble to find out if it's going to happen the way they want it to. It takes a long time to get sick enough to start producing musk. And it makes them feel awful.â
âSo why do it?â
âI told you why. The money. It's a business venture. I guess you could call it an investment.â
âWhat do they use it for? The musk.â
âPerfume,â she said with half a smile. âWhat else?â
Payne was incredulous. âThey make themselves ill so someone else can dab themselves with perfume?â
âNo,â she said. âYou're not listening. They make themselves ill to make money.â
âThat's just as bad.â
âHow is it bad?â
âTrading in your health for money? Getting rich by getting ill? It's perverse.â
âI doubt they're getting rich. For all we know, they're sending money home to their families. Making life easier for the wife and kids. Raising more snotty humans to lord it over us.â
âI'm sorry, but I can't condone that.â
âWho cares?â she said, leading Payne to believe that it made no difference either to the miners or to her. âIt's their choice. That's the difference between them and us. They get the freedom to be stupid. We get the freedom to do what they say.â
âBut not that. We don't have to do that.â
âOh yes,â she said. âWe do. Unless you want to have more adventures like the one you had.â
But Payne was not convinced. Healing was a precious thing to him. It was a gift. In a way it was the only one he had. And he would not have it for long. No healer did. Which was all the more reason not to be reckless with it, or to squander it, or to practice it unscrupulously.
âThey need us, Vecque. We can use that as leverage. When they come to us, we can talk to them. We can teach them. There have to be other ways to make money. Higher wages, better prices for the ore, I don't know. But I do know that they don't have to walk around half-sick.That's no way to live. It has to take a toll on them. If they stay that way too long, the condition might become permanent. They might not ever be able to be fully healed.â
âYou're missing the point again. They don't want to be fully healed. And if at some point they change their minds and do, and can't be, well, that's the risk they