friends in college. Actually, Claire and Dana were friends first, and Dana introduced us. We all shared a house together one summer.â
âHouse?â snorted Mrs. Abernathy. âThat dump?â
âAnd did they get along?â I asked, ignoring Mrs. Abernathyâs commentary.
âSure, we did everything together. Until Dana started dating Trevor.â
My ears perked up. âTrevor? As in TrevorââI scanned the seating chart to find the usherâs last nameââReckholtz?â
âYes, Dana and Trevor hooked up our senior year. Claire was a little jealous, I guess, because sheâd had a crush on him, but they got past it eventually.â
I put a check mark next to Claireâs name. I didnât really think she had it in her to kill someone, but âlove triangleâ way beats âwouldnât flirt back with uncleâ in the rock-paper-scissors of murder motives.
âTell me more about Danaâs relationship with Trevor,â I prodded.
âOh, well, you know,â Nicole said, stalling. âIt ended.â
âHa!â chortled Mrs. Abernathy. âIâll say it did.â
âIt ended badly, â Vince amended.
âThatâs putting it mildly,â said Mrs. Abernathy. âNow that I think about it, with all she put him through, I wouldnât blame him one bit!â
âWhat do you mean?â
Nicole looked hesitantly at Vince, who sighed and nodded at Nicoleâs unasked question. âGo ahead and tell her,â he said. âItâs not like we have to protect her reputation. At least not anymore.â
Protect Danaâs reputation? This was going to be good.
âI donât know,â Nicole said. âI donât want to get Trevor in trouble.â
âOh, for heavenâs sake,â said Mrs. Abernathy. âYou might as well tell her! I think he looks good for it, myself.â
âLooks good for it?â I had to bite my tongue to keep myself from reacting to Mrs. Abernathy talking like a TV homicide detective. Next sheâd start referring to him as the âperpâ and Dana as the âvic.â
Nicole sighed. âTheyâd been dating for about a year, and things were going really well, but then Dana got pregnant.â
â Pretended to get pregnant,â Vince interjected.
âWe donât know that,â said Nicole. âShe said she was pregnant, and I believed her. Anyway, she wanted to get married. He kind of freaked, but eventually he agreed to do it.â
âKey word being âagreedâ to,â said Vince. âHe never would have even considered it if it werenât for the baby.â
âAnyway, we were all busy trying to throw a wedding together in a month, because she wanted to do it before she started to show. But then Trevor started acting really weird. He said she didnât seem all that pregnant, but what would he know?â
âShe never had morning sickness, and she didnât even have one of those, what do you call it? Baby lumps?â said Vince.
âBump,â continued Nicole. âBut every woman carries her pregnancy different.â
âThatâs right,â said Mrs. Abernathy, âand Dana was carrying hers in her head.â
âAnyway,â continued Nicole, âwe were going shopping for bridesmaidsâ dresses, and Dana had a doctorâs appointment later that afternoon. Trevor texted her, âIâm coming with you.â And she was all, âYou want to shop for bridesmaidsâ dresses?â and he was all, âNo, Iâm coming with you to the doctor.â
âShe said she didnât want him to come, but he made a big deal about it. At some point, she stopped texting back and turned off her phone. By then, we were at the bridal shop anyway. But then Trevor showed up and they had a big fight. He said if there was a baby in there, he wanted proof. They were