insisted. âWhat was he wearing when you found him?â
âMr. Archer, we have questions.â
âYou told them what you saw?â he asked Lila.
âYes, of course. You mean the fist, the dark sleeve? Yes.â She paused a moment. âOliver wasnât wearing a dark shirt, was he?â
âYou saw a flash of movement,â Waterstone reminded her. âIn a dimly lit room, and through binoculars.â
âThatâs true, but in that flash I saw a dark sleeve, and if Oliver wasnât wearing a dark shirt, he didnât push her. I shouldâve seen his face. Ash said Oliver was six-one. Why didnât I see some of his face over her head when he had her against the window?â
âIf you remember your statement,â Fine said patiently, âyou said it happened very fast, that you were more focused on her.â
âThatâs all true, too, but I shouldâve seen some of his face. I shouldnât have seen a dark sleeveânot if Oliver Archer pushed her.â
âBut you also didnât see anyone else in the apartment.â
âNo, I didnât.â
Fine shifted to Ash. âWas your brother in any trouble? Do you know of anyone whoâd want to hurt him?â
âNo, not that I know of. Trouble didnât stick to him.â
âAnd you never met Sage Kendall, whom he was involved with,living with, who purchased one of your paintings for a five-figure price tag? Upper five-figure.â
âI knew I couldnât afford it,â Lila muttered.
âI never met her, and he only recently told me about herâas I told you in my statement yesterday. He didnât push her. He didnât kill himself. I know why Iâm sure of that, but why are you thinking it?â
âYou had some problems with your brother,â Waterstone pointed out. âYour half brother.â
âHe was a frustrating pain in the ass.â
âYouâve got a temper, been known to throw a punch.â
âYeah, canât deny it. I never threw one at Oliverâit wouldâve felt like punching a puppy. And Iâve never hit a woman, never will. Check on it, dig into it, look all you want, but tell me why youâre not sure this is what it was made to look like.â
âI can go outside or into the other room if you donât want to talk about it in front of me.â
Fine just looked at Lila, then shifted back to Ash. âAnd whatever we discuss, youâll pass right on to her.â
âSheâs done the right thing all the way down the line. And she showed a complete stranger genuine compassion when she couldâve just told me to leave her alone, sheâd already done enough. Why wouldnât I tell her? And she doesnât leave the room for anyone.â
Lila could only blink at that. She couldnât think of the last time someone had stood up for herâor had to.
âYour brother had a mix of alcohol and barbiturates in his system,â Fine said.
âI told you, heâd never have mixed pills with alcohol.â
âHe had enough of both that the ME believes he would have ODâd if he didnât receive medical attention. The MEâs findings are that your brother was unconscious at his time of death.â
The hard look on Ashâs face never changed. Lila knew, as she was watching him.
âOliver was murdered.â
âWe are now pursuing this as a double homicide.â
âSomeone killed him.â
âIâm so sorry.â Going with instinct, Lila leaned over, laid a hand on his. âI know itâs what you believed all along, but itâs . . . Iâm so sorry, Ashton.â
âWrong place, wrong time?â he said slowly. âIs that what it was? They put him out, but they smack her around, scare her, hurt her, push her. They finish him off so it looks like he killed himself in regret or despair. But she was the one they hurt,